Episode 84

full
Published on:

21st Nov 2026

Fixed Price Contracting: What You Must Know Before Signing

Fixed price contracting means knowing exactly what your project will cost before construction begins. Sounds like the ideal setup — but it only works when the scope is defined, the materials are specified, and the homeowner understands what they're locking in.

Bill Reid and Chad Eslinger sit down for a builder roundtable on the two contracting methods nearly every homeowner will choose between: fixed price and cost plus. This episode follows Episode 82, where Chad and Bill covered cost plus contracting in detail. That conversation ran long — they originally intended to cover both methods in one episode but realized each deserved its own deep dive.

Chad brings a Pacific Northwest new-construction perspective with 29 years of experience doing both fixed price and cost plus. Bill brings 35+ years operating exclusively fixed price in high-end Silicon Valley remodeling. They agree on the fundamentals: the contract type matters less than the work that goes into it.

WHAT YOU'LL DISCOVER

The difference between estimate, quote, and bid. Chad explains the three levels of pricing and what each one requires. An estimate is wide-range, square-foot-based, first-meeting numbers. A quote is tighter, built on assumptions about materials and scope. A bid is locked — you're committing to perform specific work for a specific price. Most homeowners think they're getting bids when they're actually getting estimates.

What goes into a true fixed price number. Bill's design-build process documented every material down to cabinet door styles, edge profiles, wood species, and finishes. His team produced detailed drawings for his construction crew — millwork elevations, tile layouts, the full scope. Chad requires elevational drawings for cabinetry, tile, and finished carpentry before he'll lock a price. Without that level of detail, the number is fiction.

Why pre-construction matters more than the contract type. Fixed price only works when scope is defined. If plans lack detail, specifications are thin, and materials aren't selected, you're fixing the price on assumptions. Chad's rule: if you're not willing to pay for pre-construction, you shouldn't be doing a fixed price contract.

What type of client benefits from fixed price. Bill's clients were busy high-tech professionals who wanted peace of mind during construction. They valued knowing the number upfront and were willing to front-load the decision-making. Chad sees fixed price working best on remodels where the homeowner feels the existing space and understands what they're asking for. New construction clients often want flexibility to adjust once they can stand in the framed rooms.

The danger of competing six builders. When you ask multiple builders to price quickly, you incentivize estimates built on low assumptions. The lowest number wins — and the homeowner pays later when scope wasn't captured, materials weren't specified, and change orders pile up. Both builders agree: if you're going to compare, compare the deliverables, not just the bottom-line number.

Why Bill operated design-build for 35 years. Controlling the entire client relationship — design staff, interior designers, construction crew — allowed Bill to prevent the finger-pointing that happens when architect and builder don't communicate. His team defined scope early, priced it accurately, and executed with minimal change orders. The model worked because his clients didn't have time to coordinate multiple professionals.

The role of the architect in fixed price success. When you hire a separate architect and a separate contractor, the quality of the plans determines whether fixed price is even possible. If the architect delivers a builder set with minimal specifications, the contractor has to fill in the gaps — and those gaps become assumptions that move the budget. Bill references Episode 83 with Laura Davis, the Colorado architect who offers three service levels: builder set, intermediate, and full detail. Matching the service level to the client type is what makes the system work.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

Fixed price contracting delivers peace of mind when scope is defined. When it's not, it delivers conflict.

The contract type is a symptom, not the disease. The real issue is whether the work was done upfront to define scope, specify materials, and document the project.

You get what you pay for in pre-construction. If you're not willing to invest in detailed plans, material selections, and builder involvement during design, fixed price is the wrong choice.

Estimate versus quote versus bid — know which one you're getting. Most builders are giving estimates when homeowners think they're getting bids. Ask what level of detail went into the number.

Competing builders on price alone is a losing game. The lowest estimate wins, the homeowner loses. Compare deliverables, ask how the builder arrived at the number, and watch what questions they ask you.

ABOUT CHAD ESLINGER

Chad Eslinger is a second-generation builder with twenty-nine years of experience. He's built over 150 homes, completed 75+ remodels and additions, and developed hundreds of residential lots in the Lake Oswego, Oregon area. He bought the family business in 2006, right before the market collapsed, and built it into a practice where most of his work comes from architect referrals. He also created Construction Flow, an application designed to walk homeowners through every phase of a build before they're standing in the middle of it, and he hosts the Construction Flow podcast.

Find Chad:

For Owners https://getconstructionflow.com/

For Pros: https://constructionflowpro.com/

https://eslingerhomes.com/

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ChadEslinger

Apple Podcast Spotify Podcast

chad@getconstructionflow.com

MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE

Episode 82 — Cost Plus Contracting: Builder Roundtable with Chad Eslinger

Episode 83 — Inside an Architectural Office with Laura Davis

ASK BILL A QUESTION - Call or text 530-289-6368

Voicemails may be featured on a future episode, first name only. Let me know in your message if you'd prefer to stay off the air.

Mentioned in this episode:

The Awakened Homeowner Book

The Awakened Homeowner Book

Transcript

Okay everybody. Well, as promised, Chad and I are back again to talk about another form of contracting method that a lot of contractors and builders do, and that's called fixed price contracting. Now, just as a refresher, two episodes ago — so last episode I was able to bring an architect in out of Colorado and Laura and I really got into, and we even talked about some of this stuff too, but we got into the inner workings of an architectural office.

That kind of links to everything that we're talking about here because Chad and I have also talked about the architect-client-builder relationship. And that was really good to hear from the architect as well. But the episode before that, Chad and I really got into cost plus contracting. And our goal was to talk about cost plus contracting and fixed price contracting in the same episode, but boy were we off the mark there because there's just a lot, I mean a lot to talk about. So after that episode, we decided that we would dedicate a full episode to fixed price contracting.

Now, let me put it in perspective. In my thirty-five years of operating a construction company, I operated almost exclusively a fixed price contract method for all my clients and most of my work was upper end and high end residential remodeling, renovations, teardowns, major projects upwards of two to three million dollars in the Silicon Valley area. So a lot of my clientele were high-tech people. In fact, all of them were high-tech people.

to start my business back in:

Now, here's how I operated. So what I thought I'd do is share a little bit about how I operated my design-build business in my design-build and fixed price contracting method very quickly so that we can get into the conversation. Because what Chad brings to the table is a contractor that's been doing this for twenty, thirty years himself, well over twenty years, I think twenty-nine years if I remember right, and does both cost plus and fixed price contracting.

And then for you homeowners who are listening, fixed price contracting means in the simplest terms, is you know exactly how much the project's going to cost before you begin construction. It sounds wonderful, but it's a lot of work before you actually sign the contract with a builder. A lot more work. Now, I shouldn't say it's more work. It's you're front loading. You're concentrating a lot of the work on the front end to ensure your peace of mind during the course of the project.

Now, a lot of the, all the decisions that have to be made still have to be made. It doesn't matter what kind of contract you're doing. It's how they're dispersed out throughout the process before and after breaking ground and how if you're not careful they can get diluted down to a point where you're starting to regret every day on your project. Cost plus contracting and fixed price contracting, they're both very viable options. So it's not like we're here to debate mine's better than yours.

But what we're trying to do is educate you on what really is best for you and what these things really are. Because I've been on the internet a lot lately and I'm watching and there's a lot of people talking about fixed price contracting and cost plus contracting. And it's funny how some really profess this is the only way to do it, and others profess this is the only way to do it over here. And Chad and I come from it from a little bit of different perspective. We don't think there's one way or another here.

So anyway, I'm rambling here. So what I did in fixed price contracting is the caveat here is that I operated a design-build business, meaning I had my own design staff on board. I had my own interior designers. I had my own construction staff. I had different levels of interior designers. So I did not employ an actual licensed architect on my team. What I did do though is I brought in residential designers, which I would classify as a designer that has architectural experience that worked under the guide of licensed architects. So I had a combination of residential designers and interior designers to do the projects that we did.

Now, if we had a project that escaped out of our comfort zone, then I brought in a separate licensed architect on projects. But for the most part, we did design-build. And why that's important is because I had full control as the business operator and builder, contractor, on every aspect of the client relationship, the client experience.

But regardless, all of the same principles apply whether you're hiring a separate individual architectural firm to do your design of your project and then a separate contractor. What I was doing is I just rolled these into one service for our clientele. So keep in mind that as we're talking about this, whatever I'm talking about, whatever Chad's talking about, you can roll it under one umbrella as a design-build business.

Or you can piece it together yourself, which actually I would say a majority of the people do is they hire separate interior designers, separate architectural designers, separate design consultants like engineering and surveying and civil and whatnot. But what I did is I decided to go the design-build path. And I did that my entire career. And for me it was very successful. But it's not the best fit, it's not necessarily the best fit for every single type of client. But my clients who are busy working professionals, like I said, in this high-tech world, they really responded well to it because they just didn't have the time to go running around hiring a bunch of people.

So what I did is in principle, I would force the issue, I guess I'll say, is to define the entire scope of the work of the project early on during the design process. And what I mean by that is what exactly are we doing for this home, for this project? Are we, let's scope it out, meaning a narrative about what we are going to be doing. What are the goals? What is the ultimate destination that we want to get to? And then we would design towards that goal. And we would document every single material that goes into the project. And I'm talking about every single material, the cabinetry. And I'm not saying just the cabinetry with an allowance of thirty thousand dollars. I'm talking about my design team would work with the homeowner and pick out the cabinet maker, the models, the door styles, the finishes, the edge profiles, the wood species, the colors. And then they would do the detailed design drawings for that particular kitchen and bathroom and millwork throughout the house.

And then we would price the whole set of materials out, and we would include that in our cost database for the project. So imagine that multiplied times, gosh, I think the construction categories that I had were about thirty-eight different construction categories from site prep all the way to excavation and demo and foundation and framing and then as you work your way all the way through plumbing, electrical, mechanical, cabinetry, millwork, countertops, floor, the whole thing.

And the way my chart of categories worked is I had in the most part worked from how the project progresses, right? And a lot of them were the actual construction elements. There were the construction materials, what I call construction materials, everything attached to the house, integrated, built into the house, the siding, the windows, the masonry, the roofing, the gutters, everything that was part of the structure of the home. And then there were the finished materials. And my design staff, my interior design staff focused on the finished materials and the design, not just fluffing pillows and picking out colors. And these designers actually did all of the detailed drawings for my construction crew.

Remember, in a design-build model, I am the construction crew. So I don't want to hear about it that they don't have enough information in order to order the things properly, to install it properly, because it's my butt. I can't go running off to some other designer. So what did I do? I had a vested interest in making sure that a lot of this stuff, all of this stuff was figured out before

So that we can actually execute in the field and not get that overlap of designing in the field. And all of a sudden we're making decisions that delay the project and things like that. So this is the world that I lived in for many years. Yeah, it took a while to perfect it. But the bottom line is I would provide a cost breakdown for my client by category.

I would, like I said, plumbing, electrical, mechanical. It was the work associated with the labor, the materials, the subcontractor, the equipment, everything that falls, the fixtures. If we're providing those fixtures, everything that falls in that category is one number. And that number includes my profit and my overhead and a provision in there to make sure that we're protected, and that everybody's protected, so that we don't end up having to go back to the client and say, now you want walnut wood or whatever, it's gonna be an extra charge.

So we would have a provision built into each of the categories, some room for everybody to move around in to make sure that we stayed within that budget. So keep in mind that we worked with a client very early on talking about their budget and the goals that they had. And we had different methods to break all that down, to work with them on the numbers. Ultimately, though, we got to a total dollar amount, and we would get at the end of the day before we went to contract, we had that breakdown of all the different categories.

We had to flag the items that were still not decided, because let's face it, you just could spend three years trying to get to this dream point I'm talking about and never start, never build anything, right? So at some point we had to say, wait, we don't know exactly what the roofing color is, or we don't know what the final decisions. We had detail, we were pretty far along, but on the entry door, let's say, we wanna maybe upgrade to the walnut or something. So we had some moving targets, I call them, and I would also call them hot spots during the project. And we identify those before we go to the actual contract signing.

Now keep in mind that because I did a lot of renovation and remodeling work and they were pretty complicated projects, we would have a process in place where I would bring in my construction staff. Once we were at completed schematic design, the first stage of schematic design, I would bring in my construction staff and we would do an analysis of the design versus the actual structure. We would climb around under houses, in attics, we would cut holes in walls, we would do everything that we could possibly do to make sure that number one, we understand what the full scope is. Number two, we can price it properly. Number three, that we don't surprise our client during the project with change orders.

Our goal, our mission, one of our values was to have the least amount of change orders in a project. And I'm emphasizing that, and sorry, I'm all over the place a little bit, but the reason I'm emphasizing that, two things. One is we want to be able to contract for the project, file it away and execute. There's other companies out here on the internet talking about design build and explaining their process. And some of them even go into their experiences where they actually found out they had to have a beam that had to go in that they didn't think about, right? That wasn't really clear. And my problem with that is was it discoverable? Could we find that? Could have we found that out? And if there was any doubt in our mind, and we looked at it ourselves and we said, yeah, we could have done that, then we would eat it. We would put the beam in. Sometimes it cost me twenty thousand bucks. But we would eat it.

Why? Because just like Chad mentioned his past episode, I don't spend one dollar on advertising. What I do is I invest in my client. So I'd rather spend the money on that questionable hiccup and keep the client satisfied. So that is the purpose for me in operating design build. I did not want to be running around picking out the front door two weeks before we needed it because somebody forgot and now the project's delayed. I did not want to, whatever I could do to not have to go to the client and say, that's gonna be another twenty thousand. Sorry. I couldn't do it.

Now there are cases where the client does change her mind, right? They go, no, I don't want walnut. I want Brazilian mahogany and I want this and I want that. Yeah, that happens because it moves from the spec. But anyway, that's a really short, that didn't sound like it was very short, but anyway, that was a short description of what I would do with fixed price.

Then lastly, and I'll let Chad chime in, is I would take that breakdown, that scope, and I would extract out of that the total project schedule. I would assign, I would establish progress payments thereafter based on the actual values of the items tied to the schedule. And a client would pay their progress payments based on the work performed that ties directly back to those cost structures so that it was fair for everybody, that we're getting paid for work performed, or we had to get paid to order that Brazilian walnut entry door. So that rode along the schedule, the scope. And we've talked about scope in the past, Chad and I have, about you got the plans, great, but where's the scope? Where's the specs? Where's the schedule? Where's the schedule of payments? And then we would actually execute in the field. So that's about as quick as I could have made it with design build fixed price contracting.

Chad, please shut me up. Take it away.

Chad Eslinger: Yeah. Well, so first of all, we pretty much do things exactly as you described them, whether it's fixed price or cost plus, as far as how we break things down, how we go about identifying the assumptions that constituted the budget that you created for each of those line items as you described it. But I think you said something that really I wanna spend a few more minutes on, which is you mentioned that there were certain individuals that were a better fit for that. The people you were working with in the technology sector were a good fit for that.

Because for me, that is one of the determining factors of whether we go fixed price or cost plus is the people and their project. And so you also alluded to the timing, how you could literally work on a project for years and just keep spinning and refining and then things will change and you could do that for an eternity. But I find that also is a function of the people and their project. So I'll give you for instance on that. A lot of times we're getting referred by architects, which means these people have bought a piece of property. And there's also the difference between remodels and new. So I'm talking about new right here, but somebody would have bought a piece of property and gone to an architect, they're excited, they're ready to go. They don't want to wait a year or three years to spin on all their decisions. And some of the designers that they all bring into these projects don't want to do that either.

You had the situation where you controlled all that, which is I think pretty optimal for doing something on a fixed price method. But in this case, on say a new home when somebody's ready to go, they're wanting to do it in a period of time, and they're also a lot of times hung up on certain things. I'll give another example. We do a lot of vaulted great rooms. They're two stories high and they'll have a fireplace detail that is got a lot of options in how they do it. So casing it out in stone and millwork. And a lot of people will say, you know what, I need to see this space to know how I'm ultimately gonna design this. I need to be able to stand in my great room and look at it.

And that's another big difference between remodeling and new is at least in a remodel, with the exception of additions, they can feel the spaces. They can stand inside of them and have a little bit better time visualizing them. And I feel like in remodels, in my experience, has been those are the ones that we have to do the most forward planning on because we're going to move a little bit faster. There's going to be less time to make decisions in the field. And I 100% agree with your point about not wanting to be the reason that something slowed down on the project was because we didn't do the work up front to identify that front door, like you referenced in your example. So

In a remodel, we need to pick everything well in advance and order it because we're also normally removing people from their day-to-day lives. So they're either going into a corner of the house and staying there during the remodel or they're moving out altogether. And so I find that the individual homeowners are way more accepting of doing upfront planning and doing it thoroughly because they understand that once we get going, any stop is them being pulled away from their kitchen.

Chad Eslinger (:

Basically where I was going with those examples was the concept of when somebody is a good fit for doing a job that is dialed in from the very beginning versus there's some people who truthfully want to have a little bit of flexibility baked into the process. And I see that way more in new construction because the people want to be able to physically stand in the spaces before they make some final decision. So there's certain categories that really become a little bit more budget driven when that happens, or we can assign certain expectations, like you had mentioned, assigning a walnut cabinet or certain things. And so you would account for that within there.

Sometimes, and this is what we talked about in the last episode too on the cost plus version, is sometimes we're baking in a little bit of flexibility, whether we're calling those a fixed number or whether we're calling those a budget number, so that there is a little bit of room for the client to move. If, for instance, there was something that was really hard for them to make a decision on, and there was an option A and an option B, and they really couldn't make a decision in the moment, and we don't want this to go on for years in the planning, and so we pick one and we say this is our assumption moving forward. And either we do or we don't bake in a little bit of buffer for that. That act is actually something that I'm very curious about. I'm going to give an example on the new home side, then I would love to hear from you how you accounted for those buffers that you mentioned.

But if we're building a big new home from the time we're first planning it and creating the numbers till the time that we actually execute those things, there can be numerous price adjustments, just even something as simple as insulation or drywall. So not dependent upon a decision that the client made, but dependent upon the material prices changing. If we're going to maybe have two price increases in, let's say drywall from the time we do contract till the time we install drywall, how do we then pick the number that we fix for drywall? And this is one of the things that caused me to start to drift away from fixed price a little bit because I wanted to try to make it as fair as possible for my homeowners. Because for me, as the builder, if I was to protect myself, I'd have to put what I thought it would increase plus some percentage, or just say, hey, I'm going to be open book and show you exactly what this is and that's what we're going to charge. So this was a debate that I was having internally. I would love to know from your perspective for a similar situation like that, how did you account for that? Or did you find that if they were more remodels, were the timelines not so long that was happening as much to you?

William Reid (:

Well, that's a really good question. I think probably one of the biggest points, right? So it depends, and this goes back to the client type that you're talking about, right? So some clients are a lot more price conscious than others, right? And some can tolerate a certain amount of turbulence in a project and others can't.

So when it comes to your drywall example, we would get, first of all, it goes all the way back to the foundation of the design and the scope, right? And making sure that there was a clear understanding of the scope. It wasn't as much material costs because, frankly, if drywall goes up or down two or three or four percent material, really in that particular trade, I think it's 70% labor anyway. So in the relative scheme of things, a three percent material cost increase over thirty percent of that particular trade, it doesn't really move the needle that much in that particular example. But there's other examples that could move the needle a lot, right?

But the best way that I manage that is from the front end. So by designing it thoroughly. By documenting the scope. And when I say scope of work too, remember that the scope of work transfers streams a couple different directions, right? The scope of work streams to my contract with my client. It's streamed to my estimating department, if you will, which half the time was me. But anyway, it's streamed to the estimating department to make sure they understand the scope that goes with the plans out on the table, the scope's in the hand, with the specs, and that scope and spec goes to the subcontractor, right?

So that subcontractor is holding that scope of work and those plans. Drywall tape and texture the entire kitchen and family room, and bedroom one, two, and three, and bathroom four, down the hallway. We're going to leave the ceiling, but refloat the ceiling, so on and so forth, right? So we would go to that extent to make sure that we could get accurate costs from the subs and that we could hold them accountable, right? So that is one of the biggest things that we did. And it does sound daunting to do that, but once you get in a rhythm of that in business operations, man, does it make things a lot easier.

And then the other thing we would do too is we would have what we would call a site inspection process. Now I talked about the meeting that we did early on for my construction guys to go, yeah, you think you want to open up that wall? Well let's take a look. Let's check, and they would do their site assessment and then we would get into value engineering. But then we would have a separate meeting on site once the design was more firm and more locked in, say towards the end of design development. We would have another site inspection with all the subs and trades and anybody else that we were going to depend on to do the job and to price the job, right?

So we would bring them out, we would hand them the scope of work, they would look at it, they'd walk around, they would see things and they'd go, wait, if you're going to do this wall, you're probably going to have to do that wall. If you're going to, so many variables came up that we would then revise, this is all pre-contract, right? We would revise the scope of work, then we would get either a revised bid from the sub if we had already had one, or we would get the bid from the sub then, and then we would roll that into our actual final cost to the client. So I guess what I'm trying to say is we tried to capture and cut it off at the pass as much as we could so that we didn't run into the problem.

Now that all that said, to go to your question, it's like let's say it's the front door, right, that we were talking about earlier. And there were still not a final decision made on the front door, but we have an idea, right, of what they want. We know it's 72 inches by 10 feet tall, with two side lights and a transom, and it's going to look like this, the inspiration picture from an image. And we probably think it's this. We're not 100% sure, but we do have some vision and idea. If we have zero vision idea, that's a different conversation. But we have some idea.

So we would go to our door supplier and say, look, we're not 100% sure. What we want is a realistic budget for the client so that we can put that into the cost and then declare that to them and say, okay, look, this is probably pretty close. It's probably going to be twenty thousand dollars for this front door system. But just so you know, if you move away from some of these different ideas and you go to their studio and you find something else, the number could probably move on you. But this is pretty darn close.

So this is like an allowance, but it's not an allowance, right? Allowances, in my opinion, in my experience, are nobody did anything. They just stuck a twenty thousand dollar or ten thousand dollar number in the line item and we'll figure it out later. And that gets multiplied 10, 20, 30, 50 times on a project in some cases. We'll just figure it out later. We'll just figure it out later. Let's put 10,000 in for the cabinetry. Let's put 10,000 in for the front door.

Let's put $5,000 in for just the tile material, and then we'll just work our way through it and figure it out. This is where that margin now is so huge that the odds of somebody getting pissed off, frankly, later on in the process is much greater.

So again, with my business model, I told my design staff, I said, okay, look, we've got to start the project. We need to start the project. Our crews are ready. So let's go ahead. And of course, I'm forecasting this two, three months ahead of time. And I say, okay, look, I want you to push to narrow it in so that we can then take a certain amount of responsibility for any overages. So if we tell the client, okay, this is our scope, we know there's a variable, and okay, well, now you want glass in the front door also, and that's another couple grand on a $2 million project or a million dollar project. Honestly, we wouldn't charge a client for that. We would just absorb that into our scope because we didn't want to unnecessarily rock the boat with a client and we want them to feel like we did a good enough job in the due diligence up front.

In order to be able to absorb that. Of course, that can't happen too many times, otherwise your profit margin as a builder starts to really erode. But it all depends on how serious you take the, and I know you do, but I'm talking to the world out there, how serious you take your client relationship, how much you want that client to be your advocate for you after the job's done. Because I'd rather spend $2,000 on a piece of glass than $5,000 on marketing to get what I call more victims. So that was always my philosophy.

Now sometimes the numbers got a lot bigger than that and then we had to have a conversation with the client. But it always boils back down to the scope wasn't clearly defined, the materials weren't clearly specified. And this is where I struggle with some of these contractors that do cost plus contracting, not like you do it. And if you go back, you guys go back and listen to how Chad does his cost plus, it's different, I think. I would say it's not the norm for what a lot of cost plus contracts do because what Chad's doing is almost like a hybrid version where he's going to do cost plus, but I'm still going to try to figure a lot of this stuff out. So there's not as much surprises.

Yeah, well, so you kind of nailed it right there, which is the difference isn't what kind of contract you're using, fixed price or cost plus. It's what was put into that. I think in the last episode we talked about deliverables too. So then how is that information conveyed back to the homeowner in a way that they can understand? So we did all this work in pre-construction, and then how is that relayed back to the homeowner? So it's very clear when you get to that point where inevitably there's a change, what was the original expectation that we set and hopefully even why did we set it. Because a lot of times we did it based on a specific reason. It may have been budgetary, the reason that we did that. It may have been based on the design. It may have been based on continuity of materials, lots of different things, inspiration pictures, lots of different reasons. But if we don't have something to go back and look at and relate to it, I think the underlying issue behind all of the emotions that go behind why we do these things is trust.

And you kind of alluded to it there. You'd much rather have the trust and the confidence in your client, even if that meant spending a few more dollars on the glass in the front door or whatever it was, versus going out and marketing for the next client who hopefully things go better with. You want to try to maintain that all the way through. I look at it as even through the warranty period because we're still owning that product even after we've been paid. So the last thing we want is for trust to erode even down the road about the way things were done. And at the end of a project is one of the most sensitive times because when we are changing things, a lot of times they all come to a head at the end.

But I think it's so funny that you talk about, I think it also has a lot to do with contractors' experiences. So you're talking that your experience has been that you've seen people using cost plus doing it in a lazy way. So assigning bulk budgets and then kind of running with that thinking, well, it's going to be what it's going to be anyway. And since I'm showing you the bills, I sleep good at night. Those things were just placeholders, versus people do. The funny thing is in my experience, and this is just probably market by market and who we know as builders and who we talk to and who we get to kind of see under the hood on how they're doing things, that I see it the opposite way around here in my marketplace, where a lot of the builders doing fixed price do the exact same thing that you described builders doing with cost plus.

And I think a lot of this does have to come back to something we talked about in the last episode or the first episode we did actually, where it's how committed is the client to the home builder? So when a client is asking a bunch of home builders to price a project for them, number one, they're probably going to get a mix. So some builders are going to give their pricing as a fixed price, some are going to give it as a cost plus. But if they're competing and they know they're competing, and a lot of us know who our competition is, then what is that process incentivizing the contractor to do? Is that process incentivizing the contractor to assign low budget numbers to things in order to get the job? And my experience is that just has so much pain on the back end of it that it's just not worth it. I've played that game, I've been there. It's part of the value engineering too. So I'm not saying that we shouldn't do that. I'm just saying for the clients out there who are listening, just be very careful about the motivations. It's the famous saying, show me the motivation, I'll show you the outcome. What are you pushing people towards? Is it a race to the bottom and getting the lowest price? Because I think most experienced contractors would say that's the recipe for hard times in the project somewhere. And a lot of it is exactly what you described, of putting a low budget number in without enough thought going into it.

And that can extend in my world. See, you were doing your own designs, but in my world, a builder could look at a plan that was designed by another architect and just assume all the notes on there are exactly what the client wants and totally miss the boat too, because the clients don't always, in my experience, know what every detail on their plan truly represents. Whereas if you guys were doing like elevational drawings, so let's say for tile, were you doing elevational drawings to figure out where the niche is? Is there a bench?

Very detailed, yes.

Right. So we're not getting that most of the time. So even a really diligent builder, if he doesn't or she doesn't have all those elevational drawings, I would say same for cabinetry, same for finished carpentry. If you don't have elevational drawings, even if you do know I'm using an oak cabinet or I'm using a paint grade cabinet, you still may miss that whole third dimension of what does it look like in elevation versus in plan view. So there's just so many variables. We could talk about all the little things that drive all this all day long. But I think the biggest takeaway for a homeowner listening to this should be just understand what's going into the numbers that you're being presented. Ask for an example of it so you can see it for yourself and go through it, like a project that this builder done for another client, so you can see what that looks like and make sure that it's clear what's going into this. I think that's where these things start to get hairy, is when something wasn't clear, now there's a dispute, and what are we going off of to resolve this dispute? Am I eating that as the builder because I didn't do a good enough job of defining it, or was it just not well enough defined by whoever's responsibility that was? Because in design build, you're taking all responsibility. If people out there are working with someone who isn't design build, who is wrapping their arms around all those responsibilities and owning it?

Well, yeah, I mean, I think this is the foundation, a big foundation of the topic today. And I've always struggled with this: the quality of the design and the plans and the specifications, regardless of who does it, whether it's in the design build business model or not. And most people building homes are not selecting design build, as far as I know. I think most people are going what I call the more conventional path.

So when a homeowner goes to a design professional and they go to start planning their project, I think one of the purposes today is to let a homeowner know, and I think this is what's great about this podcast is both sides are listening. Well, three sides are listening. We've got the design pros, we've got the construction pros, and then we've got the client right in the middle.

And so if a client goes to a design professional, architect, interior designer for remodel or whatever, I think it's important for you, the homeowner, to understand that it begins, however it happens, it begins with the quality of the plans, the design details. And when I say quality, what I mean is an architect and designers can design high quality plans that are still not enough in order to comfortably enter into any kind of contract with a contractor. So it, and also the homeowners can also unknowingly restrict the design professional from providing the information that they don't know they need. What I mean by that is not paying for their services.

So the plans themselves, the designs and the specifications, have to be achieved one way or another at some point. This is really the crux of all of this. Regardless of the contracting method you choose, and the builder you choose or anything, everybody's going to be asking the same questions. And sometimes your questions are too late, so you have no control. So all of a sudden you're making compromises on your home design, you're making financial compromises you had no idea coming. Again, design build or conventional method.

At some point, you as the homeowner need to be aware of what level of details that you have to protect your experience during the process. And you also, telling your design professional, now that hopefully Chad and I are getting you a little bit more information to even be able to ask the question, but when you're meeting first meeting with your architect, open up the conversation about the type of contract you'd like to do. You know, what are your priorities? I want to get started as fast as possible. Okay, well then, you know, let's talk about what compromises you will have to make in order to do that. It could be design compromises, it could be cost compromises, it could be comfort level compromises when things start to move on you, both design and cost.

So from a homeowner's perspective, opening up that conversation also lets your design professional understand: okay, these are the kind of people that I can do my builder set. And that's what Laura Davis said from the Colorado architect. She has three levels. She offers the builder set, she offers an intermediate set, and then she offers a full blown every single detail, everything, every single spec. So Laura, what she does, if she starts interviewing a client and she's trying to figure out what kind of client are they, and then she'll offer the three different services and try to steer them in the right direction, not necessarily to the cheapest one, not necessarily to the expensive one. It's like, here's a client that's remodeled their home five times, here's a client that's built five homes before, here's a client that's hired contractors before. We could probably get away with the builder set or maybe the mid set because they're going to be driving and picking and doing everything.

Okay, well, here's a client that's never done anything before. They just had a windfall. They have a bunch of money. They want to build a beautiful modern, their aspirations are huge, and they've never done it before, like I said. So we better talk about maybe the level three plans so that the builder, as the expectations are set for the builder, accountability is there, expectations are conveyed, the homeowner's expectations are conveyed from the architect to the builder so that everybody has a chance to succeed. And so that's my little tangent there on you knowing as a homeowner, what do you really have to sink your teeth into to protect your experience.

And I will say that that's an interesting way that architect chose to do the three levels because that's one of the questions I ask my clients when we first meet is what set of numbers are you looking for? See, this wasn't a question you were asking because you had one way to do it. Do you want an estimate? Do you want a quote or do you want a bid? And those are the same kind of three levels. So the first one of the estimate is normally cost per square foot, round numbers, stuff like that, where you're throwing those budgets like you described at things that weren't well thought out.

That's your quote level.

Yeah, I'd be like, no, that would be the estimate level.

Okay.

Estimate level is, it's normally the first conversations that people are having with builders. They're always asking, you know, how much is it going to cost and how long is it going to take? So in order to answer that question, normally in a first meeting, you have to have that kind of verbiage around it. You know, so many dollars per square foot based on what I see here or a range. Same with a remodel, you know, this kitchen may be between X and Y price as a range so that you're at least, check that you're in the same atmosphere as far as where your pricing is.

Okay. I think it's important for people to understand. So when you, in your world you use the word estimate as the lowest tier, the widest range, you know, hence the word estimate. But people gotta be careful because other people use that word as here's your construction estimate based off of your plans and your specs and everything. So

Yes.

so just, so the, more of that awareness thing. So you go estimate, quote, which

Bid.

quote implies that you're quoting off of something, like actual, and then bid is what's the difference between quote and bid?

So I actually had to look up the definitions of both those words to really wrap my head around that. Because what I

Yeah.

the reason that I did this is because I realized that clients had expectations in their mind of what these numbers represented. And I wanted to make sure that I was aligning myself with that. So a quote versus a bid, there's a lot more certainty in a bid. You're saying I'm giving you this number to perform this scope of work. A quote is saying I'm giving you these numbers for this set of work according to these assumptions. So the bid is a more dialed in version of a quote. So the

Okay.

quote is where most people end up in my world, kind of like you said, the architect with builders ends up with a lot of people in that builder package because the builder is driving a lot of the formation of the numbers in that scenario. Because unless you're a design build team, you're wrangling up all the resources, the designer and all these outside, you know, geotechs and engineers and stuff like that. And so most people that I work with anyway want to be dialed in, but the whole getting to the bid thing, they struggle with wanting to do 100% of the selections up front. And it, I think it has to do a lot with the size of the projects that we're doing because they're primarily new homes. They're primarily multimillion dollar homes on properties that have complicated site work to them. Up here in the Pacific Northwest, stormwater is a huge issue for us, and it's unique to the percolation rate on your

piece of property

Mm.

and then do you have trees where that thing needs to go and you know there's all sorts of little variables that also make it very hard to get to a bid on some of those numbers unless you have everything you know 100% done before you put the number together.

And some of that comes back to whether you have a bank involved or whether it's cash. These are all the variables that would again go into, like you're saying, what is this mix of variables that go into what's the proper setup for you as the homeowner? Is it a fixed price? Is it a cost plus? Like I mentioned earlier, I saw most of my fixed price or bids being remodels because number one, they're in the home and so their feeling of rush is less than when you've just bought a piece of property and you're writing a mortgage check for it every month to the bank, or you've got your money tied up in it. If you bought it in cash, there's a different level of urgency for a lot of those homeowners to get moving. They want to get going. Whereas when people are in their home and they're enjoying their home, I find that those people tend to, just for me, this is my experience, be a better fit for going deeper into the numbers and getting closer to what you do, closer to that bid. And if they're doing that and they have a bank involved, then that can also drive some of these decisions.

There's some banks that only will accept fixed price contracts. Like that's all they'll take. And so sometimes that drives it. So there's all these variables. Again, if the homeowner understands what goes into these things, then hopefully we've armed them with more information to decide what's best for them. And even though I see this all the time, I'm dealing with one right now. The clients, we'd had this whole long conversation about all of these. They're still wanting to get six bids on a house. And I'll be meeting with them again soon and just asking, what are you expecting from me versus these other numbers?

Frankly, what happens sometimes with me is a couple of big, really good jobs I did recently. I was bidding or quoting against four other builders, five other builders, and I asked both of them, these are two huge jobs that I did that I won the job on both of these, and I said, based on the numbers that you're getting from other people and the timelines that you're getting them within when you want to make your decision, that will impact what I'm able to do for you. Because if someone wants to make a decision in 30 days on a builder or two weeks, whatever, I'm not going to get there. I'm not going to get to a bid, nor are they committing to a pre-construction process with me in that scenario. So that is partly what drives a lot of these estimates. When clients want to get a bunch of quotes and do it in a fairly short period of time because they're eager to get going, I understand why they want to do this, but I think this is very important for the clients out there to know that again, we're talking about what's the motivation or the incentive.

Well, in this case, you're asking someone to move quickly and compete against other people. So what happens is those normally end up being more estimates than anything else because the builders don't have, even if there is a plan, to turn all that information around and to go through a proper process of talking to the architect and the engineer and sitting down with the homeowners and going through the plans, that normally isn't happening until after they pick their builder. So it's a weird way to go about it, but it happens all the time. And I understand homeowners want to get a sense for pricing so they don't feel like they're overpaying or being taken advantage of. But when you do that, you're going to get a poor set of numbers and then you find people picking based on who they like and maybe how good their sales pitch was and not really based on the numbers. So did they really achieve what they were trying to achieve by comparing multiple sets of numbers when it's done like that?

Yeah, I mean, boy, you talked about a lot of things there. I mean, the estimate versus quote versus bid. And if you don't know, meaning you the homeowner don't know where you're at when you're talking to a builder, are they providing you an estimate, a quote, or a bid, and what are they basing that off of? And homeowners need to understand too that you're going to want to listen to who you're dealing with, right? I mean, quality home builders are not necessarily the most polished, salesy, lovable people, frankly. I mean, you're talking about somebody who's a technician, who's a mechanic, who's a visionary, who can see. These people can see your home built before they even dig any dirt, right? They've built the home in their heads to a certain level. And frankly, that's how a lot of times they can figure out how much it's going to cost.

But so when you're talking with somebody at the early stage, six different builders, which by the way, I think is a huge mistake because you're just going to get nothing but confused. You're going to get estimates all over the place. And guess what? Ooh, look at that one. That one looks really good. It's low. And you know what? And by the way, I really liked them. You know, his kids play soccer at the other field that we're at. You know, I mean, this is where you get into trouble, right? You love the person, and then all of a sudden that shadows over. Did he ask me any questions? Did he ask me what driveway I want? What kind of driveway I want? Well, it wasn't on the plan. It just says new driveway. What did they price in? They priced in gravel. Right?

And but now that I'm thinking about it, when I was talking to Chad, he had a list of 50 questions before he gave me any numbers. Have you thought about the driveway? Have you thought about the drainage system? Have you thought about, do you want cultured stone or real masonry? Do you want real stone? I mean, you have got to pay attention to what these builders are asking you because this is who they really are. Forget about the price because if you go with Ace the Builder, who is, everybody's best friend, and he gives you that number, and you get attracted to that and you dive into it, not only are you going to probably pay a hell of a lot more than what you were told, it's going to be miserable because your expectations were back at that one million dollar number. And here you are nine months into it, and you're at 1.5, and you didn't know it. And as you think about the other guys that you were talking with and they were asking you questions and they were interested, some of them may have even called your architect and wanted to clarify a few things. And there's a value there, right?

And the reason why there's value, one of the reasons why there's value is getting this information up front allows you to still stay in the driver's seat. Nobody asked me about the driveway. Now I want to know how much, what's the difference? You know? I think I want to do the pavers. I don't want to go gravel. I want to do the pavers. But okay, but instead I'll go cultured stone over here. Or you know, you're in the driver's seat, you as the homeowner to work with a builder who cares, right? That's interested in providing the solutions to you.

So this goes back to one of the first things that we wanted to cover, which was what type of client really are you? Are you going to get sucked in to the low ball number and pay the price later? Are you the type of client that wants to understand all the details and know for the most part within 85% that you know how much this thing's going to cost me, right? And are you that kind of person? If you're that kind of person, you want to slow down, get the right technician, the right builder to work with you on getting to lock in that number and take your time because what's going to happen is you're going to be able to sit back and watch that guy go to work and achieve your dreams. So that's the client, the different type of client type.

And by the way, the perfect storm is go with Ace the Builder at $1 million and do a cost plus contract. Because guess what? Every single thing is going to cost more, likely. Right? More than you thought. Right. If you go with a Chad type builder who says, okay, look, we could go cost plus. We can go fixed price. If you want to go fixed price, I need a month or two more. And let me hammer all these details out. Let's go back and meet with the architect. Let's meet with the designers. Let's get our arms around at least a little bit better so I can say to you, it's going to be 1.4, 1,489,000. Of the 400 decisions, there's 30 that still need to be made. And this could move it 10, 15%, you know, whatever. You know, I don't know exactly what your exact process is, but

know, and now you know going in. It's not one million dollars and it's going to be one point five no matter what. It just depends on how painful and ugly the experience is. And the other thing too is a true custom home builder that is open to doing fixed price or cost plus is also going to deliver a product that is more what you expected. The quality of the materials, the quality of finishes. You go in down in the bottom, all of a sudden the comp roof you have in mind is the cheapest comp roof that you can get, right? As opposed to the trilam heavy profile roof that you have in your pictures in your mind. All of a sudden you show up, the cheapest tract home comp roof is going on your home. Nobody asked you. They asked you what color. Yeah, I want a dark black color. Okay, great. Boom, it's on.

Multiply that disappointment level times a hundred or two hundred if you don't hammer out the details.

The thing I'd like to add to this is in the preparation phase, just like in the build phase, you get what you pay for. So the people who are willing to pay for a pre-construction, I don't know how if you guys did that through your design build. Was that a separate line item, the design element of it or the pre-construction element of it? It sounds like they were committing to you when they did that. You weren't just doing this.

Yeah, we would have a design retainer. We would have a separate design agreement and a separate construction contract. And that evolved out of what the homeowners were telling me, asking me for. At first they didn't want to fully commit to the entire project until they knew what they were getting themselves into. So I don't know, twenty eight years ago I came up with this separate design. It's not ingenious. It's just here's a separate design process, here's a separate construction process. And then it crossed over and we're always talking back and forth about budget. And so yeah, we would have a retainer that they would pay to begin, kind of like you're saying, pre construction, which we need to be talking about that someday too. What is pre construction?

Yeah, and maybe this is the segue into that because what I'm describing is a lot of that where people are coming and they're wanting to get this information from builders. Without, they're not paying for pre construction from six different builders when they're talking to them. So I didn't really close the loop on that thought. I started with these high end homes that I was competing for. They wanted to get a decent set of numbers, but in one case they had the plan developed. In another case, they knew what it was going to be, but it was still being developed. And I groused about this and complained and almost didn't do it, but they both asked for an estimate. They said, just give me an estimate. We understand. So I showed them my deliverables and said, but I don't want to do this if I'm competing against five other builders. I'm not just going to do that for free.

Right. Right.

So I did on both of them. Thankfully I knew the architect's plans well enough that I could give them a really close estimate, even though plans weren't fully developed. And then they did pick from those estimates. And I do believe that by me showing them my deliverables, that had a lot to do with why they picked me because they knew what they would get. And then once they committed to the project, then we would move forward with turning that into whatever they wanted it to be, the quote or the bid. And then from there it's more about what we just were talking about for the last bit of our conversation.

How do you commit to the project at the estimate level? When you say commit, do you mean they're assigning like a contract?

No, but we can do a pre-construction contract like you described for that part. But what I'm saying when I meant that was of the six builders, they're saying you're my guy, we're picking you, we're moving forward with you, we're not continuing to talk with other people and get numbers from them. We made our pick.

So in like informally, like yeah, let's just move ahead with you. And there's still a certain level of trust there so that you don't get taken advantage of.

There is, and to your point, there's also levels of deliverables. So if somebody wants to get to that bid level, then maybe that does look different and it has a different type of pre-construction package assigned to it. But the challenge is as a builder who gets a lot of projects that come through referrals, it's very rare it happens, but that someone says this is the only guy, like you don't need to talk to anybody else. It's normally when that happens, a very close relationship between the client and the referring source. So like close family friend, maybe a realtor they're really close with and very much trust, and sometimes that does happen. I'm doing one now where that was the case. But most of the time they're talking to multiple people. And so how do you get from I'm talking to six builders to I'm getting sets of numbers that mean something, and then all the way to your construction documents? And I think that's what we're wrapping our arms around today is for the homeowners to understand it starts with what you asked for. So if someone came to your door, they were asking you to do that design phase. But when someone comes to a builder's door like myself, I'm not the only one they're talking to typically. And so it's just you're starting a process that it's good to have this information we're sharing today as you go down that road to understand what are you asking and what are you kind of incentivizing from these builders who you're talking to.

Okay, well it's pretty apparent that we're going to continue coming up with topics for Chad and I and all my guests here. But what I think we should do is let's wrap up this episode that was originally intended to shed some light on fixed price contracting. And it's obvious that we're going to have to keep talking about this, but let's go ahead and hit the main points and then talk about what we're probably already going to address in the next episode. Take it away, Chad.

Well I think the perfect place to wrap this up is the transition into the next phase, the next conversation, which we haven't talked about at all during this, which is the process of doing all this work, which is kind of baked into the way that you do things as a design build builder, which is the pre-construction process. It's all the work that goes into setting up these expectations, the scope of work, the pricing, all this stuff. That process is commonly referred to as pre-construction, although a lot of people will call it different things and they'll do it in different ways. But ultimately that is the, let's call it the umbrella term for all of the work that goes into getting a proper contract prepared that covers all these things we've been talking about. That process is commonly referred to as pre construction. So you get what you pay for in that regard. If you engage somebody, whether they end up being your builder or not, to help you define all these things that you need for your project, the scope of work, the elevation drawings, all these things we've been talking about, you are going to have a better outcome with less gray area and less moving budget numbers. Whereas on the opposite, now this is whether it's fixed price or cost plus, if you don't do that, you are going to end up with things that are assumptions in those prices because you haven't spent the time to thoroughly talk it out, design it, detail it with elevations and all the things you need to truly lock a number in. If you don't do pre-construction, you probably shouldn't be doing a fixed price contract. Is that fair to say from your experience?

Yeah, yeah, because what are you going to fix the price on, right? If you don't know.

Correct. Budgets and assumptions that weren't fully vetted and thought through.

Which is just scary as hell. And a lot of people, even when they're in the middle of the nightmare that everybody talks about, they still don't know why they're there, right? They're starting to blame everybody else but themselves. And it's not their fault. It's because they didn't know. So yeah, be sure if you're going to go fixed price, you know what you're

price you're fixing the price on. There's guys out there saying, you want a fixed price? Are we building a tract house or are we building a palatial estate before you even answer that question?

Chad Eslinger (:

And I would add to that, if you're doing cost plus, make sure you know what's in that cost plus estimate. It's the same concept. I think we've agreed on everything we've talked about today, which is so interesting because we're talking about it from two different ways to do it, but the underlying concepts that make it work well or not are the same.

William Reid (:

Right. That's right, for sure. And just hitting that point again, what kind of client are you? Do you want that peace of mind wanting to know the number? Then take the time, fix the price on something real so that you can, and sometimes it takes a lot more time, but you're gonna get what you want and you're gonna know what you're paying. If you're in a hurry and you wanna get started, it can work with cost plus if you have an architect builder relationship and the three of you can actually pull off a successful cost plus contract because the architect and the builder know each other, right? And they lean on each other and you can lean on them and you can get your project going. But keep in mind that if you're gonna go cost plus, getting six bids from people you don't know, and maybe your architect doesn't know all of them or know them all very well, is the recipe for disaster. Add 50% to your budget, and maybe you'll hit it.

All right. Well, that was great. I think let's wrap it up, everybody. I guess Chad and I are gonna be stuck at the hip here for a while as long as he can tolerate me. And we'll think about the next episode. I'm Bill Reid, your home building coach. And yep, that's right. We're here to enlighten, empower, and protect you. Let's go make it happen.

Show artwork for Your Home Building Coach with Bill Reid

About the Podcast

Your Home Building Coach with Bill Reid
Your Ultimate Guide to Building or Remodeling Your Dream Home
I'm Bill Reid and I will be along your side as Your Home Building Coach. Brought to you by The Awakened Homeowner Mission— your go-to podcast for real talk about designing, remodeling, and building your dream home! Hosted by Bill Reid, who's helped coordinate the design and construction of hundreds of new homes and remodels, this show is packed with insider secrets and smart strategies to help you crush your home goals.

Building or remodeling can feel like a wild ride — but it doesn't have to be a nightmare. Here, you’ll get expert home remodeling advice, practical new home construction tips, and a full scoop on building a custom home without losing your mind (or your budget).

We’ll walk you through renovation planning, share step-by-step home remodeling guides for homeowners, and spill the tea on common home building mistakes and how to avoid them. Thinking about diving into a remodel or new build? Find out exactly what to know before starting a home renovation and how to navigate the home building process like a pro.

This podcast pairs perfectly with Bill's new book, The Awakened Homeowner — a must-read if you’re serious about creating a space that feels like home and makes smart financial sense.

Whether you're sketching ideas on a napkin or knee-deep in construction dust, Your Home Building Coach gives you the best tips for building a new custom home, real-world advice, and all the encouragement you need to stay inspired.

Ready to turn your home dreams into a reality? Hit subscribe and let's make it happen!

About your host

Profile picture for William Reid

William Reid

Home design and construction consultant William Reid is an extraordinary individual with an absolute passion for construction. His journey began at a young age, and at 22, he became a minority shareholder in a startup construction company with his mentor. His passion and hard work paid off, and in 1992, he launched his own company, RemodelWest, which rapidly grew into a full-service design and construction company. With decades of experience and expertise, Bill has successfully developed processes and systems meeting the demands of building and remodeling, making him a true master of his craft. Now, he is on a mission to share his wealth of knowledge, empowering homeowners to enjoy the experience of creating their new homes through The Awakened Homeowner podcast, the accompanying home building book and platform. Get ready to be inspired and energized by Bill’s incredible guide and system to build or remodel your home